Grade by Grade
A. Creating Canada, 1850–1890 · Creating Canada, 1850–1890

British North America in 1850: Setting the Stage

A1 A2 A3About 45 minutes
Learning goals
  • I can describe the colonies, Indigenous nations and peoples of what is now Canada around 1850.
  • I can use the four historical thinking concepts to ask strong questions about 1850 to 1890.
  • I can explain why one event can look very different from different perspectives.
  • I can compare one part of life in 1850 with life in Canada today.

Words to know

British North America
The British colonies north of the United States before Confederation, such as the Province of Canada, Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, Prince Edward Island, Newfoundland, and later Vancouver Island and British Columbia.
Province of Canada
The colony created in 1841 by joining Upper and Lower Canada. Its two halves were called Canada West (now southern Ontario) and Canada East (now southern Quebec).
Rupert's Land
The huge area draining into Hudson Bay that the Hudson's Bay Company claimed for trade. It was, and is, the homeland of many First Nations and of the Métis Nation.
Confederation
The joining of colonies into one country. Canada was created by Confederation on July 1, 1867.
historical perspective
Seeing an event through the eyes of people who lived it, using evidence about their beliefs, values and situation.
continuity and change
Asking what changed over time and what stayed the same.

Let's start with a question

In 1850 there was no country called Canada. Forty years later, in 1890, Canada stretched from the Atlantic to the Pacific, with a railway joining the two coasts.

How did that happen so fast? And here is the harder question a historian asks: who gained from it, and who paid the price?

In this unit you will investigate the years 1850 to 1890, when Canada was created and grew. You will meet politicians and railway builders, but also First Nations and Métis leaders, Black newspaper editors and pioneers, Chinese workers, women and newcomers. Each of them helped make Canada, and each saw it differently.

Squared-log houses, a stone house and a white wooden church with a steeple along a dirt road lined with split-rail fences at a heritage village.
Reconstructed villages like this one show what a small settlement in Canada West looked like around 1850. Historians treat buildings and objects as evidence, just like letters and documents. AI-generated image

Remember from Grade 7

In Grade 7 History you studied Canada, 1800–1850. You learned about the War of 1812, the Métis Nation at Red River, the treaties before 1850 (including the Robinson Treaties of 1850), the Underground Railroad and Black communities such as Dawn and the Elgin Settlement at Buxton, the Rebellions of 1837–38, the Act of Union (1840) and responsible government (1848).

This unit picks up the story right where that one ended.

The map around 1850

  • The Province of Canada had two halves: Canada West (mostly English-speaking, now southern Ontario) and Canada East (mostly French-speaking, now southern Quebec). They shared one legislature.
  • On the Atlantic coast were the separate colonies of Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, Prince Edward Island and Newfoundland.
  • On the Pacific coast, Vancouver Island became a British colony in 1849. The mainland colony of British Columbia was created in 1858, during a gold rush.
  • In between lay Rupert's Land and the North-Western Territory. The Hudson's Bay Company (HBC) claimed them for the fur trade, but they were the homelands of many First Nations, the Métis Nation and, in the Arctic, Inuit, who governed themselves and lived by their own laws.
PacificVancouver I.and B.C.Rupert's Landand North-WesternTerritory(Indigenous homelands)Province ofCanadaN.S.N.B.P.E.I.AtlanticSchematic, not to scale. Newfoundland not shown.
A schematic picture of the main regions around 1858, from west to east. Water is shown in blue at each end. This is not a real map and is not to scale.

Who lived here?

The peoples of British North America in 1850 included:

  • First Nations, such as the Anishinaabe, Haudenosaunee, Cree, Blackfoot (Siksikaitsitapi), Dene, Mi'kmaq and many nations on the Pacific coast.
  • Inuit, across the Arctic.
  • The Métis Nation, centred at Red River and along the rivers of the Northwest.
  • French-speaking Canadiens in Canada East, and Acadians in the Atlantic colonies.
  • English, Scottish and Irish settlers, many of them recent arrivals.
  • Black communities, some going back to the Loyalists and the War of 1812, and many new arrivals who had escaped slavery in the United States.

Over the next forty years, newcomers would also arrive from China, Germany, Iceland, Russia (Mennonites) and elsewhere.

Your historian's toolkit

You will use the same four historical thinking concepts you used in Grade 7, but you will push them further:

  1. Historical significance: Why does this matter? How many people did it affect, how deeply, and for how long?
  2. Cause and consequence: What caused it? What were the short-term and long-term results? Were some consequences unintended?
  3. Continuity and change: What changed between 1850 and 1890? What stayed the same? What is still the same today?
  4. Historical perspective: How did people at the time see it? Be careful not to judge the past only by today's values, and be careful not to excuse harm by saying "everyone thought that way then". Many people at the time spoke out.
One event:BC joins Canada, 1871Historical significanceWhy does it matter? Who didit affect, and for how long?Cause and consequenceWhat caused it? Whatfollowed, short and long term?Continuity and changeWhat changed after it?What stayed the same?Historical perspectiveHow did different peopleat the time see it?
The four historical thinking concepts are four different questions you can ask about the same event. Each one leads to a different kind of answer.
YearEvent in this unit
1850US Fugitive Slave Act; more freedom seekers come north
1853Mary Ann Shadd's Provincial Freeman first appears
1858Black pioneers settle in Victoria; colony of British Columbia created
1864Charlottetown and Quebec Conferences
1867Confederation: the British North America Act
1869–70Red River Resistance; Manitoba joins
1871British Columbia joins; Treaties 1 and 2
1873Prince Edward Island joins; North-West Mounted Police formed
1876The Indian Act
1883First federal industrial (residential) school opens on the Prairies
1885North-West Resistance; CPR completed; Chinese head tax
Some key dates in this unit, 1850 to 1890.
Worked example

Modelled example: Asking strong questions

Turn this weak question into strong inquiry questions using the four concepts: "When did British Columbia join Canada?"

  1. The weak question needs one fact (1871). It asks for no thinking.
  2. Significance: "How significant was the promise of a railway in British Columbia's decision to join Canada?"
  3. Cause and consequence: "What were the consequences of British Columbia joining Canada for First Nations on the Pacific coast?"
  4. Continuity and change: "What changed and what stayed the same for Black residents of Victoria after British Columbia joined Canada?"
  5. Perspective: "How did Indigenous peoples, settlers and Chinese workers in British Columbia see Confederation differently?"

A strong inquiry question is open (more than one possible answer), needs evidence, and usually asks why, how, to what extent or from whose point of view.

Words for this unit

Historians and communities today use respectful words. Say First Nations, Métis and Inuit (together, Indigenous peoples). Say enslaved person and freedom seeker. You will see older words like "Indian" in documents and law names, such as the Indian Act. Historians quote those words accurately when naming a law or source, but do not use them as everyday words.

Hands-on activity

Then and now: a family comparison

You need: paper, a pencil and a grown-up or older relative to interview.

  1. Make a chart with three columns: Topic, 1850 (what you think), Today.
  2. Pick four topics: how people travelled, how news spread, who could vote, what school was like.
  3. Fill in the Today column first with your family's experience.
  4. Make a careful guess for 1850, then check your guess as you go through this unit and correct it.
  5. Circle one thing that has changed a lot and one that shows continuity (stayed similar).

Look for: guesses like "by horse, boat or on foot" for travel and "newspapers and letters" for news; noticing that in 1850 only some men could vote; noticing continuity, such as people still living in some of the same towns and First Nations still living in their homelands.

Just for fun

What do you call a question that needs only one fact?

A closed case. What do you call a question that needs evidence, perspectives and an argument? History class. 🔍

Your turn

1

Was there a country called Canada in 1850? Explain.

2

What were the two halves of the Province of Canada called, and what are they today?

3

Which company claimed Rupert's Land?

4

Name the four historical thinking concepts.

5

Name three groups of people living in British North America around 1850.

6

What is wrong with the question "When did PEI join Canada?" as an inquiry question?

7

In what year did the colony of British Columbia (on the mainland) begin?

More practice: warm-up

1

In what year did Confederation happen?

2

What does "continuity" mean?

3

Which ocean is on the east coast of Canada?

4

In what year did responsible government begin in the Province of Canada (from Grade 7)?

5

What do we call First Nations, Métis and Inuit together?

More practice: on your own

1

Why is "Rupert's Land was empty" an inaccurate statement?

2

Explain the difference between a short-term and a long-term consequence, using an example from your own life.

3

Give one reason we should not judge people in 1850 only by today's values, and one reason we should still name harm.

4

Turn "Who was Louis Riel?" into an inquiry question about significance.

5

Why might a newspaper written by a Black editor in 1855 describe Canada West differently from a government report?

Challenge

1

Canada grew from four provinces in 1867 to seven by 1873. Suggest why this growth might be described as a success by some people and as a loss by others.

2

A classmate says: "History is just a list of dates." Use the four concepts to argue against this.

3

Choose one topic from the timeline above and write a strong inquiry question that uses two concepts at once.

Check your understanding

Quiz

1.

What were Canada West and Canada East?

2.

Which historical thinking concept asks "What changed and what stayed the same?"

3.

Which statement about Rupert's Land in 1850 is accurate?

4.

Which is the strongest inquiry question?

5.

When was Canada created through Confederation?

6.

Why should historians avoid saying "everyone thought that way then"?

For parents and teachers

Big idea: This lesson sets up Strand A (Creating Canada, 1850–1890). It previews A3 (significant events, developments and people), A2 (investigating perspectives) and A1 (comparing life then and now).

How to help: Do the then-and-now chart together and add to it through the unit. Encourage open questions: when your child asks "when", follow up with "why" and "who did it affect".

Heads-up: This unit includes hard history: residential schools, armed conflict in 1869–70 and 1885, racism against Black and Chinese Canadians, and the loss of Indigenous lands. Each lesson has a note for you. The aim is honest, age-appropriate learning that also highlights people's courage, leadership and contributions.

Common difficulties: Thinking Canada existed before 1867; describing the West as "empty"; asking only one-fact questions.