Grade by Grade
C. Canada, 1929–1945 · Canada, 1929–1945: Depression, Extremism and the Second World War

Canada at War, 1939–1942: The Air Training Plan, the Atlantic, Hong Kong and Dieppe

C2.3 C2.5 C3.1 A1.4About 75 minutes
Learning goals
  • I can describe Canada's major military contributions from 1939 to 1942.
  • I can explain the importance of the British Commonwealth Air Training Plan and the Battle of the Atlantic.
  • I can describe what happened at Hong Kong and Dieppe and assess their consequences.
  • I can interpret statistics and schematic diagrams as historical evidence.

Words to know

BCATP
The British Commonwealth Air Training Plan (1939 to 1945), which trained aircrew from Canada, Britain, Australia, New Zealand and other countries at bases across Canada.
convoy
A group of merchant ships sailing together, protected by warships.
U-boat
A German submarine.
corvette
A small, fast-to-build warship used by the Royal Canadian Navy to escort convoys.
merchant navy
The civilian sailors and ships that carried cargo; Canadian merchant mariners were among the war's most dangerous jobs.
prisoner of war (POW)
A member of the armed forces captured and held by the enemy.
amphibious assault
An attack launched from the sea onto land.
total war
A war in which a country uses all its resources (people, industry, money) for the war effort.

Approaching this lesson

This lesson and the next describe battles in which many Canadians were killed, wounded or captured. They are described factually, without graphic detail. Behind every number is a person with a family, and many Canadian families still remember relatives who served.

Hook: a small country, a huge effort

In September 1939 Canada's armed forces were tiny: a few thousand regular soldiers, a handful of warships and a small air force. By 1945, more than one million Canadian men and women (from a population of about 11 million) had served full-time, and Canada had one of the largest navies and air forces among the Allies. How did Canada build such a war effort, and what did it cost?

The aerodrome of democracy: the BCATP

In December 1939, Canada agreed to host the British Commonwealth Air Training Plan. Canada had wide open spaces, was out of range of enemy aircraft and was close to American factories.

  • Air schools opened across the country, from Prince Edward Island to British Columbia.
  • By 1945 the plan had trained 131,553 aircrew: pilots, navigators, wireless operators, air gunners and others. Most were Canadians.
  • U.S. President Franklin Roosevelt called Canada "the aerodrome of democracy."

Many BCATP graduates served with RAF Bomber Command over Europe, including in the RCAF's own No. 6 Group. About 10,000 Canadians died serving with Bomber Command, one of the heaviest losses of any Canadian service. Bombing German cities was meant to destroy industry and morale; it also killed many German civilians, and historians still debate its morality and effectiveness.

The Battle of the Atlantic, 1939 to 1945

Britain depended on food, fuel and weapons shipped across the Atlantic. German U-boats tried to sink those ships.

  • Merchant ships sailed in convoys from Halifax and Sydney, Nova Scotia, protected by warships. The Royal Canadian Navy built dozens of small corvettes for escort duty and grew from a handful of ships to hundreds.
  • The most dangerous zone was the mid-Atlantic "air gap", beyond the range of land-based patrol aircraft, until longer-range planes closed it in 1943.
  • In 1942, U-boats even entered the Gulf and River St. Lawrence and sank ships close to Canadian shores, including the passenger ferry Caribou in October 1942.
  • Canada's merchant navy sailors faced great danger. More than 1,600 Canadian and Newfoundland merchant mariners died. For decades they did not receive the same veterans' recognition as the armed forces.

The Battle of the Atlantic was the longest campaign of the war, and Canada's largest contribution at sea.

A North Atlantic convoy (schematic, not to scale)Halifaxand Sydney,NSBritainfood, fuel,weapons"Air gap" (to 1943)beyond reach of land-basedaircraft: U-boats mostdangerous here▬ merchant ships in columns◇ escorts (corvettes, destroyers)Supplies sailed east in convoys guarded by warships; U-boats hunted them.
Convoys were safer than ships sailing alone because escorts could protect them. The air gap in the middle was where U-boats did the most damage until 1943. (Schematic, not a map.)

Hong Kong, December 1941

In late 1941, 1,975 Canadians, mainly from the Royal Rifles of Canada (Quebec) and the Winnipeg Grenadiers, were sent to help defend the British colony of Hong Kong. Many were not fully trained. On December 8, 1941, hours after attacking Pearl Harbor, Japan attacked Hong Kong. The garrison surrendered on Christmas Day.

About 290 Canadians were killed in the battle. The survivors became prisoners of war and endured years of brutal treatment, hunger and forced labour; about 267 more died as prisoners. More than 550 of the 1,975 never came home. The defeat shocked Canadians and increased fear and hostility toward Japanese Canadians at home (Lesson 13).

Dieppe, August 19, 1942

Canadian soldiers had been training in Britain since 1939 but had not yet fought in Europe. On August 19, 1942, 4,963 Canadians, with British commandos and others, made an amphibious raid on the German-held port of Dieppe, France. The plan went badly wrong: the landing lost surprise, the beaches were overlooked by strong defences, and tanks struggled on the stone beach. Within hours, 916 Canadians were killed and 1,946 taken prisoner.

Consequences and debate: Allied planners later said the lessons of Dieppe (the need for heavy bombardment, specialized landing equipment and not attacking a defended port head-on) helped make D-Day succeed in 1944. Historians still debate whether those lessons justified the cost.

The Dieppe Raid, August 19, 1942: Canadians involved01,0002,0003,0004,0005,0004,963Took part916Killed1,946Taken prisonerSource: Veterans Affairs Canada, Dieppe Raid Memorial inscription.
Of the 4,963 Canadians who took part, more than half were killed or captured in a single day.

Secret war: Camp X

In December 1941, a top-secret training school opened on the shore of Lake Ontario between Whitby and Oshawa. Camp X trained Allied agents in sabotage, radio and other skills before they were sent behind enemy lines. It was linked to British Security Coordination, an intelligence organization run from New York by Winnipeg-born William Stephenson. Its powerful radio station, Hydra, relayed secret messages across the Atlantic.

Canada at war, 1939 to 1942Sept. 1939Canada declares war; firstconvoy leaves HalifaxDec. 1939BCATP agreement signedJune 1940France falls; Canada isBritain's largest allyuntil 1941Dec. 1941Battle of Hong Kong; Camp Xopens1942Battle of the St. Lawrence;Dieppe (Aug. 19)
The first years of the war were mostly about supplying and training, plus two costly defeats. (Events evenly spaced, not to scale.)

Interpreting numbers as evidence (A1.4)

Statistics need context:

  • Compared with what? 916 killed at Dieppe in one day; 359 Canadians killed on D-Day, when about 14,000 landed (next lesson).
  • Proportions: more than half of the Canadians at Dieppe were killed or captured.
  • Who counted, and how? Casualty figures come from military records; some numbers (like merchant navy deaths) were counted later and may vary between sources.
  • What numbers hide: wounds, prisoners' suffering and families' grief.
Worked example

Let's analyse the significance of Dieppe using evidence

Was the Dieppe Raid a pointless disaster or a costly lesson? Use the numbers and consequences.

  1. Facts: 4,963 Canadians took part; 916 were killed and 1,946 captured, so 2,862 (about 58%) were lost to the Canadian army in one day.
  2. Short-term consequences: a major defeat; grief across Canada, especially in the regiments' home communities; German propaganda used it.
  3. Long-term consequences claimed by planners: lessons about bombardment, specialized landing craft and armoured vehicles, and avoiding head-on attacks on ports were used to plan D-Day.
  4. Weighing: some historians accept that lessons were learned; others argue many could have been learned without such losses, and that the raid was poorly planned.
  5. Judgement: a costly disaster from which important lessons were drawn; whether they justified the cost remains debated.

Dieppe was a costly defeat (about 58% of the Canadians involved were killed or captured), and its significance lies partly in lessons for D-Day, though historians still debate whether they justified the losses.

Hands-on activity

Convoy simulation

You need: about 20 small objects (coins, buttons or pasta), a large sheet of paper or a table, and a die. (Keep small objects away from younger children.)

  1. Draw a strip across the paper: Halifax on the left, Britain on the right, and a shaded air gap in the middle.
  2. Round 1, ships sailing alone: move 10 objects across one at a time. For each object crossing the air gap, roll the die: a 1, 2 or 3 means it is sunk. Count how many arrive.
  3. Round 2, convoy with escorts: move 10 objects together in a block. Roll once for the whole convoy in the air gap: a 1 means you lose 2 ships; any other number means all get through.
  4. Compare the results and do each round three times.

What to look for: convoys usually lose fewer ships. Explain why: escorts protect the group, and a single convoy is harder to find than many separate ships. (This is a model; real losses depended on many factors.)

Your turn

1

What was the BCATP, and why was Canada chosen to host it?

2

How many aircrew did the BCATP train?

3

Why were convoys used in the Battle of the Atlantic?

4

What was the mid-Atlantic air gap?

5

What happened to the Canadians sent to Hong Kong?

6

Give the Canadian losses at Dieppe.

7

What was Camp X?

More practice: warm-up

1

What is a U-boat?

2

From which two Nova Scotia ports did many convoys leave?

3

On what date was the Dieppe Raid?

4

Which two Canadian units defended Hong Kong?

5

What did Roosevelt call Canada?

More practice: on your own

1

Why was the Battle of the Atlantic so important to the whole Allied war effort?

2

Why did merchant mariners feel their service was not recognized?

3

How did the defeat at Hong Kong affect Canada at home?

4

What percentage of the Canadians at Dieppe were killed or captured? Show your work.

5

Why is Bomber Command's campaign debated by historians?

Challenge

1

Which contribution was more significant to Allied victory: the BCATP or the Battle of the Atlantic? Justify your answer.

2

Using historical perspective, explain why Canadian leaders agreed to send soldiers to Hong Kong in 1941, and assess the decision.

3

Dieppe and Hong Kong were both defeats. Why might Canadians still remember them as important?

Check your understanding

Quiz

1.

What was the BCATP?

2.

Why did convoys protect merchant ships?

3.

When did Hong Kong surrender to Japan?

4.

How many Canadians were killed at Dieppe?

5.

Where was Camp X?

6.

Why were merchant mariners' contributions overlooked for years?

For parents and teachers

Big idea: This lesson covers Canada's military contributions from 1939 to 1942 (C2.3), the effect of the war on groups such as merchant mariners (C2.5) and individuals such as William Stephenson (C3.1). It practises interpreting statistics (A1.4).

Sensitive content: War deaths and prisoner experiences are described without graphic detail. There is no "Just for fun" box.

Common difficulties:

  • Mixing up Hong Kong (1941, against Japan) and Dieppe (1942, against Germany).
  • Percentages from casualty figures. Work the Dieppe calculation together.

How to help: If you have a family member who served, look up their service record together through Library and Archives Canada, or visit the Canadian Virtual War Memorial online and find someone from your community. Treat these as primary sources.